Parenting philosophy
9–14 questions, scored on your device. Nothing is saved unless you sign in or choose to send it.
- approaches
- 16
- points
- 15
- questions
- 9–14
Every one of these works for the families it suits
The shapes are drawn from each approach's own positions, so two that look alike are alike. Nothing here is styled to favour one over another.
Attachment parenting
Closeness first: respond fast, keep them near, trust the bond to do the work.
RIE / respectful parenting
Slow down, narrate, and let them finish it themselves.
Authoritative
Warm and demanding at once: clear limits, explained, and held.
Gentle parenting
Connection before correction, and never through fear.
Positive discipline
Kind and firm together, with the child in on the decision.
Montessori at home
Prepare the room, then get out of the way.
Free-range
Real independence, real risk, and much less supervision than your neighbours use.
Unconditional parenting
No punishments and no rewards, including praise.
Behavioural / structured
A clear rule, a known consequence, no negotiation in the moment.
Traditional authority
Adults are in charge, the way you were raised, and it is not up for discussion.
Low-demand, high-warmth
Warm, available, and very few rules imposed from above.
Simplicity parenting
Fewer toys, fewer activities, a strong rhythm, and a slower week.
Conscious parenting
The work is on you, not on the child.
Collaborative problem solving
Kids do well if they can, so find the missing skill, together, in advance.
Good enough
Reliably imperfect, on purpose.
High expectation
Ask for more than comes easily, and hold them to it.
What this topic looks at
None of these has a right end. The last few are about what your week allows, not what you would prefer.
Responding
- R1Response to distress
- How quickly you move when your child is upset, and whether the upset itself is something to fix.
- let them work through it ↔ step in and settle them straight away
- R2Behaviour or feeling
- Whether you deal with the behaviour in front of you, or with the feeling that produced it.
- what they did ↔ what is underneath it
- R3Physical closeness
- How much bodily closeness the early years involve: carrying, contact, where everyone sleeps.
- their own space, early ↔ carried, close, sleeping near us
Direction and limits
- D1Structure
- How much of the day is settled in advance, rather than decided as you go.
- we take the day as it comes ↔ a predictable rhythm and clear rules
- D2Who decides
- Where a disagreement actually gets settled: worked out with the child, or decided for them.
- we work it out with them ↔ the adults decide, and explain
- D3Consequences
- Whether breaking a limit leads to something you impose, and how reliably.
- no imposed consequences at all ↔ the same consequence, every time
- D4Praise and rewards
- Whether good behaviour and effort get rewarded, or noticed without a reward.
- describing what is there ↔ praising and rewarding freely
Autonomy and risk
- A1Doing it themselves
- Who puts the shoes on, once the child could do it themselves and it would take four times as long.
- doing it for them while they are small ↔ letting them do it badly, from early
- A2Risk
- What you do about the climbing frame that is slightly too high.
- removing the hazard ↔ letting them meet it
- A3Expectation
- Whether you ask for more than comes easily, and how hard.
- their own pace, no push ↔ high expectations, and pushing
- A4How full the week is
- How much of a child's time is filled with something an adult arranged.
- unstructured time, boredom is fine ↔ activities, outings, things laid on
Where guidance comes from
- G1Where guidance comes from
- What you reach for when you genuinely do not know what to do.
- instinct and observation ↔ research, books, a named method
- G2Whose needs count
- Whether a parent's own limits count in a decision, or are something to push through.
- the child's needs come first, always ↔ the adults in the house count too
What your life allows
- C1Consistency that can be heldabout your week
- Not what you would like to manage. What actually happens across a real week, bad days included.
- it varies — by the day, and by who is on ↔ the same line every time
- C2Bandwidthabout your week
- How much time, energy and adult help there really is. A fact about your life, not about you.
- running on empty ↔ having room for this
Where two approaches differ
What each asks, and where the difference shows up on an ordinary Tuesday.
- Attachment parenting vs Authoritative
- Attachment parenting vs Behavioural / structured
- Attachment parenting vs Collaborative problem solving
- Attachment parenting vs Conscious parenting
- Attachment parenting vs Free-range
- Attachment parenting vs Good enough
- Attachment parenting vs High expectation
- Attachment parenting vs Low-demand, high-warmth
- Attachment parenting vs Montessori at home
- Attachment parenting vs Positive discipline
- Attachment parenting vs RIE / respectful parenting
- Attachment parenting vs Simplicity parenting